DotGNU Project - GNU Freedom for the Net








DotGNU's Vision for Webservices

Frequently Asked Questions

What are webservices good for?

When a program is implemented as a "webservice", its functionality can be used by other programs which can be implemented in any programming language, and which can run on any computer which is connected to the internet. This makes it possible for example that multiple users in different parts of the world can interact with a single set of data.

How do you define "webservice"?

"Webservices" are any services that are offered on the web (regardless of what technology is used to provide them).

In order to turn this statement into an actual definition, these explanations need to be added:

   a) With "service" we mean not only that some functionality is
      provided, but that there should also be some description of
      this functionality, namely how the service should be used and
      what it provides.

    b) With saying that the service is "offered on the web" we mean
      that it's offered over a computer network (e.g. the internet
      or an intranet) via standard protocols, i.e. protocols that
      are open, widely published, and freely available for anyone
      to implement.

It is sometimes useful to distinguish between "webservice components" which are meant to be used by other webservices, and "webservice applications" which are meant to be used by humans more directly. Both "webservice components" and "webservice applications" are "webservices" as defined above.

What are the benefits of using a remote webservice ?

Apart from special circumstances (like when you need to process huge amounts of data that your local computer cannot handle) there is a benefit to using a webservice only when the same set of data needs to be accessed by multiple people, or when a user needs to be able to access the same set of data from multiple computers.

For example, the straightforward way to implement mailing list hosting is to do it as a webservice, and that is exactly what the implementors of Mailman, the GNU mailing list program, have done.

On the other hand there is little benefit from implementing e.g. a text editor as a webservice unless there are features to allow multiple users to edit the same file at the same time.

Can webservices have a better user interface than what is possible in a web-browser?

Yes. DotGNU Portable.NET can be used to implement a highly portable webservice client program with a nice user interface. Alternatively, you can use XWT to "project" a graphical user interface to the user's computer.

Is our data stored on the webservice server?

Data can be stored either locally or on the webservice server. If multiple users need to interact with the same set of data, then it should probably be stored on the webservice server.

This raises the legitimate concern of whether a webservice provide can "lock in" customers by making it inconvenient or impossible for them to get at their data; this issue is addressed in the following questions.

Can we move to a different webservice provider?

The DotGNU webservice server requires that for each webservice and each set of data that it acts on, there is an "owner of the data" who has the right to download the entire set of data together with the program which implements the webservice. Program which have been downloaded in this way can be executed in any DotGNU Secure Execution Environment on a desktop computer or on a DotGNU webservices server.

(This means that when there is a need for an application to use data from multiple sources, where no-one has ownership rights to all the data, then the application must be divided into multiple webservice components.)

Can we get source code for the webservice programs?

If all of the following conditions are met, then the webservice provider is required to distribute the source code for the webservice program to you, upon your request:

  • The webservice program has been licensed to the webservice provider under the terms of the GNU General Public License, or it is a derivative work of such a program.

  • The webservice program runs on a DotGNU webservice server.

  • You are recognized as an "owner of the data" for this webservice.

Then the webservice server will upon your request distribute the program to you in binary form. According the terms of the GNU General Public License, this implies that the webservice provider must upon request distribute the source code for the webservice program to you.

Am I obligated to give away my webservice source code?

You are not automatically obligated to distribute your source code, and you are certainly not obligated to just give it away. However, if you sell webservice services, then your customers will expect that you make them the "owner of the data" which the webservice uses, and depending on the exact circumstances that may indirectly give these customers a right to get the source code upon request. Here are the details:

If you provide a webservice using a GPL'd webservice program (which you may have modified), then the "owner of the data" will be able to obtain the webservices programs under the terms of the GNU GPL, and this implies in particular that they will have a right to get the source code of the exact version of the program which you're using. The terms of the GNU GPL also require you to make a written promise to this "owner of the data" that you will be willing to provide the source code upon request. This ensures that the "owner of the data" will know about this right to the source code.

The "owner of the data" is typically a paying customer, and the fact that the customer has a right to get the source code increases the value of the service you provide. Therefore you will be able to charge a higher price and/or close more sales.

You can use the DotGNU development tools to program your own webservices (instead of just modifying the webservice programs which are distributed with DotGNU, or which others have made available under the GNU GPL) and then your are not required to make source code for these webservices available to the customer who is the "owner of the data". However, even in these situations where you are not required to make the source code available to your customers, we strongly encourage you to provide the source code to your customers under the terms of the GNU GPL anyway. We believe that this is ethically the right thing to do, and that it will be good for your business.

Is it possible to establish strong copyleft for webservices, that allows them to be used only by Free Software?

It is probably not possible to construct a Free Software license (which operates through copyright law) which would have this effect.

Your comments please...

You are invited to add your comments concerning this at the appropriate page of the DotGNU Wiki




Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article are permitted in any medium or format, provided this notice is preserved.

This page is maintained by Norbert Bollow <nb@SoftwareEconomics.biz> with support from the DotGNU Developers mailing list.